11/12/2013 UPDATE: If you are looking for information on the box of nine friends on the new Timeline, please see this post.
(I almost wrote this in the comments of the previous post and then thought, hell, I might as well just make this its own entry.)
There was an interesting little rumor going around the internet a while back that the twenty friends listed on the side of your (pre-Timeline) Facebook profile were the twenty people who had most recently looked at your page.
Facebook
quickly asserted that this wasn't true, and that the friends listed were chosen via an algorithm that reflected which friends you most often interacted with. This made sense to most people, although there seemed to be a public consensus that Facebook threw in a few randoms just for the hell of it, to throw everyone off.
And then Timeline happened, and things got a bit more complicated...
 |
| Zuck smirks at the thought of all the minutes I've wasted thinking about this. |
Timeline replaced the list of twenty with three separate views of your friends: a small box of six at the top, a larger box of six on the upper right of your wall, and a full non-alphabetized list that's available on a screen separate from your profile. Though I have a few (hazy) thoughts on the latter two, we're only going to focus on those friends at the top today.
At first glance, it may seem as if these six friends are random. If you refresh your page, you will get a different six. But keep refreshing and you'll notice that some of the same people show up time and time again. In fact, if you were to make a list, you would find that once you reached somewhere in the vicinity of twenty-five, you would no longer be seeing any new people. (It may be twenty-four for you, or twenty-six, but generally, twenty-five seems to be the number.)
These twenty-five are (allegedly) your current "top friends" as ranked by Facebook. This list can and does change (quite a bit) and what's interesting about it is that you are the only person who can see it. When someone else goes to your profile, what they see in that box is
mutual friends (and a truly random sampling of other friends, should you share fewer than six mutual friends).
So you have these twenty-five friends, and you're going through them and yeah, okay, there are some people on there that you stalk relentlessly, so it makes sense they show up, and sure enough there are some good friends whom you always leave comments or "likes" for, and then WHAT THE HALE. There are also random people whose profiles you never look at, whom you never talk to, and whom you had forgotten existed, actually, until they showed up on this list. What's up with THAT?
It's easy enough to assume that the wild cards are the people who stalk you (why else would they be showing up?). But before you freak out thinking about all those people you, yourself, stalk who are going to realize what you're up to, let me explain why this theory is nowhere near soundproof. I call it the Kara Paradox.
Kara, my BFF, has been on my top twenty-five list for as long as I've had Timeline. I very, very rarely go to Kara's profile and Kara, who died sixteen months ago, obviously isn't looking at
my profile, nor are we leaving each other comments or ever, in any way, interacting on Facebook...so why is she on my list?
 |
| Random refresh (with a few identities removed). |
No, really.
Why the hell is Kara on my list?
Well, it turns out that you can
manipulate your top friends list without realizing it. If you've listed anyone under the "Close Friends" category, they will automatically be slotted into your top friends list. Conversely, anyone whom you list as an "Acquaintance" will
never show up on your top friends list. I had listed Kara under my "Close Friends."
Mystery solved.
Or was it?
Interested to see what would changes it would elicit, I emptied out my "Close Friends" and "Acquaintances" lists. And guess what happened to my list of twenty-five?
A hell of a lot less than you might think. For one, Kara was still there.
And then there were the wild cards (i.e., people I don't interact with or stalk) on the list who claim to "never log in to Facebook."
And then there was the curious fact that the frequency with which certain friends showed up each time I refreshed
changed depending on the time of day and the day of the week...leading me to believe that a person being currently online (even when not signed into chat) was having an effect on who was displayed.
In conclusion?
It's a lot more complicated than anything I'm able to figure out. And while I do see some recognizable patterns in my friends list, I have to begrudgingly admit that what's being revealed isn't quite as informative as I originally thought.
Can you really tell who's stalking your profile? Not with anything resembling certainty. And for me - and I'm sure for a lot of you, too - that's somewhat reassuring.